Pilot Review: Parenthood
Posted in journalism, tv on 04/22/2010 08:32 pm by Wes
It begins with a family archetype you may recognize: responsible brother, crazy father, slacker younger sibling. This new family unit of NBC’s “Parenthood” bears a superficial resemblance to the screwball Bluths of “Arrested Development,” the Emmy-award winning comedy “Parenthood’s” producers collaborated on from 2003-2006. But there are no sitcom antics to be found here—even “Parenthood’s” silliest characters have both feet firmly planted on the ground.
NBC may have missed the mark advertising their new series, touting the involvement of producers Ron Howard and Brian Grazer, who also worked on the far more outlandish “Arrested Development.” Though the commercials practically bent over backwards to highlight “Parenthood’s” comedic moments, a comedy it is not—this is family drama, through and through.
The show effortlessly pans across the daily lives of the Bravermans with an inviting openness that has left me eager for more insight into these characters each week.
So far “Parenthood” seems to be resting its weight on the sturdy shoulders of Adam Braverman, analogue to Michael Bluth, the only sane member of “Arrested Development’s” screwball family. Adam, played by Peter Krause (“Six Feet Under”) with a confident and subtle depth, at first seems to be pegged for the role of family problem-solver. But his character quickly evolves into the most attractive and watchable of the Bravermans as a father faced with the one problem he can’t fix: a son diagnosed with Asperger’s.
As the show pivots around Adam, it tackles a variety of plotlines featuring mid-life crisis sister Sarah (Lauren Graham of “Gilmore Girls” fame) and her two teenage kids, slacker brother Crosby (Dax Shepard) and workaholic sister Julia (Erika Christensen). And when the show does make the occasional turn into comedic territory, it’s largely thanks to family patriarch Zeek (Craig T. Nelson), whose grandfatherly proclivities range from sarcastic interjections to toughening up his grandson with the occasional bloody nose.
Unfortunately, “Parenthood” seems to be the kind of television show NBC has found itself utterly unable to carry in recent years: a thoughtful and well-written drama. A quick look at the past two years of NBC cancellations doesn’t bode well for “Parenthood’s” future. Dramas such as “Studio 60 on the Sunset Strip,” “The Black Donnellys,” “Kings” and “Southland” all failed to garner substantial ratings on the network.
But who’s to blame if “Parenthood” fails? NBC, for misadvertising the series, or the viewers who seem to have little interest in a drama without the gaudy sensationalism of “reality” television?
Parenthood may well be destined for cancellation, much like the short-lived series of the same name from 1990. Both series are inspired by the 1989 Ron Howard and Brian Grazer film “Parenthood” starring Steve Martin; perhaps the slice of life family focus is simply too sentimental to work in the modern era of television.
But with every new episode, “Parenthood” delivers ample depth for each character, gradually building up the family into a tight unit without a weak link to be found. Crosby’s plotline, a cliché “accidental father” scenario, gains traction as the show goes along. And Julia, torn between her long hours as a lawyer and the challenge of bonding with her five year-old daughter, stands to sneakily become one of the show’s most compelling characters.
“Parenthood” kicked off with a strong pilot and promises to become a wonderful ensemble drama… if it gets the chance. NBC recently coughed up a cool $45 million to kick Conan O’Brien out of the “Late Night” chair and hand it back to Jay Leno—surely it can afford to keep Parenthood on the air for a few months and give it a chance to build an audience. Hopefully America won’t be too busy watching “Dancing With the Stars” to notice.


